Login | Staff | Feedback | Site Map | RSS | FAQ | Mobile | Advertise With Us | Subscription Services

HomeNewsGrowth & Development

Downtown Bonita rebirth hinges on market recovery

STORY TOOLS
Share on Facebook

When Bonita Springs developed its downtown revitalization project, the plan relied on bringing new residents to the Old 41 Road corridor.

That component made sense — it was part of the Naples and Fort Myers revitalization projects, too — because downtown residents brought activity 24 hours, seven days a week to the area instead of just having a 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. crowd come for new businesses and attractions.

Unfortunately for Bonita, that plan counted on the development market to sustain hundreds of new units, which it could have easily done in the past two decades but is next to impossible now that the bottom has fallen out.

City officials and residents alike hoped against reason that the market downturn wouldn’t affect the marquee development of downtown revitalization: the upscale Imperial Landing.

The mixed-use project with restaurants, housing and shops was supposed to be the catalyst of further redevelopment, but when Antaramian Development Corp. of Naples on April 17 backed out of its contract with Bonita Springs to build Imperial Landing, the city was left with an empty 5.3-acre lot on the river that used to be a mobile home park.

Imperial Landing wasn’t the only development scheduled for the downtown area, but the others — all private projects — are waiting for a better market as well.

The Halverson & Blaiser Group has received zoning approval from the Bonita Springs City Council to put a 160-unit housing development on Dean Street near Bonita Springs Elementary School, but the company has put the project on indefinite hold.

“We’re waiting until the end of 2009 or the beginning of 2010 to see if the market improves,” said James Halverson, group president and CEO.

The loss of Antaramian’s downtown project was a blow to Halverson & Blaiser’s plans for Bonita Springs.

“We considered the Antaramian project on the Imperial River to be the centerpiece of the Bonita downtown revitalization project,” Halverson said. “It does have an impact on us; it is unfortunate they pulled out.”

The third major downtown project called for a mix of housing and commercial development near the intersection of Old 41 Road and Dean Street. The property owner — Dean Street 2005 LLC — has received zoning approval but doesn’t have a start date for construction.

Dean Street 2005 LLC officials could not be reached for comment.

“Since they own their properties outright, they have the advantage to postpone, change or tweak their projects like they want,” Mayor Ben Nelson said. “They know what the economic conditions are right now.”

One major project that is unaffected by the slowing economy is the restoration of the Shangri-La Hotel & Resort. The group of owners of the property, Lama Hana Trust, plans to continue with its vision of an organic five-star resort, which has been under way for 10 years, regardless of market conditions.

“Their plans predate the city’s plans, and they appear to postdate them as well,” said Allison DeForoor, Lama Hana spokesman. “Slow and steady appears to be the best way right now.”

However, the reopening of the Shangri-La has been a slow process, and the project timetable is completely unrelated to Bonita Springs’ revitalization plans.

“The big thing for the downtown were (Imperial Landing) and the Shangri-La to reopen,” said John Bolan, representative for Downtown Bonita LLC, which has a project of its own.

The Downtown Bonita LLC, project calls for several small businesses in an old town atmosphere near Old 41 Road and Crockett Street.

A little farther south along Old 41 Road, Jakob Hammerle — who once owned the Village Haus along the same corridor — has been trying to create an open-air restaurant out of Smith’s Garage. The project has been plagued by delays and has had trouble getting going.

Other than working with these private developers during the rezoning process, the Bonita Springs government isn’t reaching out to force their projects along.

The city is keeping the downtown revitalization project going by following through on the rezoning of the former Imperial Landing property. If the 5.3-acre parcel had the proper zoning from the beginning, it would have saved Antaramian hundreds of thousands in expenses, and the project could have started a year earlier, if not more.

By getting the rezoning without Antaramian, the city hopes it’s easier to bring another developer onto the property with a similar project. The rezoning submission has some flexibility in it, where the City Council could build a library, for example.

“We will continue to market it and look for developers for the property,” said Barbara Barnes-Buchanan, assistant city manager.

Even though the slowing market created a bump in the road, residential development downtown could still be the key to success in Bonita revitalization.

“It is a great plan, and it will really add value to that property, value to downtown,” Nelson said.

Comments

This site does not necessarily agree with comments posted below. Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. Break our rules, and we will ban you. No exceptions, no second chances. Read our privacy policy & user agreement.


Hey Johhny Bunco, You and Downtown Bonita LLC, should sub money for mouth. Finest available property in Bonita IS ideal location for small old Florida style stores (combined w/1, 2, or 3 attractions) not residential or another library --- ie 'unique" mixed use.
Talk to your boy Nelson, you'll find him in box with developers.

#1 Posted by BonitaSprings1 on April 27, 2008 at 10:59 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Isn't there a railing in front of Pelican Landing that needs attention?

#2 Posted by jim09091 on April 28, 2008 at midnight (Suggest removal)

Now the city leaders want to throw taxpayer dollars that they do not have into rezoning costs for a parcel of land that belongs to the people of Bonita. They want to do this just to help make another developer rich, or even worse several smaller developers. Why dont they just wait 6 months or a year and see what the people come up with. There are other valid uses for this property it does not have to be a condo complex, to make Bonita better. Stop the madness and do not waste another dime on this untill the people have spoken.

#3 Posted by klfeeley on April 28, 2008 at 3:53 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Please...all of this is nothing more than a lot of gum beating. We have been hearing about the Shangri La restoration for years and nothing is happening that is apparent to anyone passing by. That property has looked the same for years now.

#4 Posted by beneyw on April 28, 2008 at 7:49 a.m. (Suggest removal)

There is no need to wait to continue the re-zoning. The people have spoken load and clear on what they would like to see happen there. City officials needs to stay on track. It is not to make a developer rich... it is to help revitalize our downtown area for the residents. A mixed use project will bring residents and visitors alike.

Downtown is already looking better with the remodeled hair salon, the pottery store (very cool), our little bike shop, and our awesome park. Keep the faith people... we will have a downtown to be proud of.

#5 Posted by iamme on April 28, 2008 at 7:50 a.m. (Suggest removal)

"the plan relied on bringing new residents to the Old 41 Road corridor"

there are tons of 'new residents' in that slum area.. border crossing criminals, prostitutes and pimps, drug pushers and users... the area continually degrades. the problem is the 'residents' that are already there. why give them better buildings?

oh... i get it! NEW residents means pouring money in so these criminals will move on to slums in ft myers and lehigh. ok, i'm in

this article will get a lot of ink

#6 Posted by pit_stop on April 28, 2008 at 8 a.m. (Suggest removal)

"City officials and residents alike hoped against reason"
Unfortunately it seems there has been a lot of that concerning the defunct version of Imperial Landing, however; City Council is to be commended for rezoning the property without a developer in play.
=>1
The best use of that property would be to parcel it and sell it off as individual lots to create an arts village with the City retaining the waterfront for activities and flooding buffer as Alex Grantt so wisely proposed. Although the market is slow, a Riverfront specialty project would sell out. Competing with Coconut Point makes no sense, let's leave that up to Coastland Mall and 5th Avenue South in Naples. Besides we have more to offer with the river setting.

=>2
The hotel part of Shangri-la has low ceilings and communal bathrooms. It is built like Fort Knox whereas rehabing it for central air conditioning and individual bathrooms presents a daunting task. I took several builders through it in the early 90's when Coldwell-Banker had it listed for sale. The unanimous verdict I received was that it would be easier and cheaper to bulldoze than to gut and rehab. I admire the people who took on that challenge.

#7 Posted by alancodi on April 28, 2008 at 9:12 a.m. (Suggest removal)

City officials and residents alike hoped against reason that the market downturn wouldn’t affect the marquee development of downtown revitalization: the upscale Imperial Landing.

hmmmm,,,, sounds to me we have a city that likes to take a gamble and roll the dice with tax payer money by hoping and praying for the economy, investors and the real estate market.

a city thats going broke cause they were relying on impact fees and development to fund the city isnt a very smart city,,,, does anyone on city council have a college degree?

#8 Posted by Chenzo on April 28, 2008 at 9:40 a.m. (Suggest removal)

bonita springs city council.. educated? you mean at a school?

bu-bu-bu-bush, hillary, obama, mccain...... nelson, arends....????

since when did education, intelligence, common sense, honesty or even morals matter when it comes to politics and politicians?

it's spending money and promises always broken.

....and our fellow taxpaying registered voters actually VOTE for these clowns? lol

we have mccain-obama-hillary.. the three stooges to vote for, which is not that different than recently having the nelson/arend ballot circus. what more proof do we need to see what's wrong with our city and our country?

go downtown in Bonita Springs and look at the vacant lot, see the hookers and the "loiterers" on your way to buy 3.60 a gallon for gas.

#9 Posted by pit_stop on April 28, 2008 at 10:25 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Who said that revitalisation depends on the economy? A journalist! Revitalisation depends on whether the people of Bonita have the will to clean up the crime. Until now they don't. Why? Because it's not easy, and it will cost money. No one will invest money there until we clean it up. Shangri La won't open because if decent people have to drive through downtown to get to their place they will not come back, and they now it.

#10 Posted by docwatson on April 28, 2008 at 3:55 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Doc, I agree about Shangri-La. It can never be a 5 star resort. Can someone please tell me why we have to make old 41 upscale. We just need a destination. Make it historical or Little Havana or artsy or organic, my goodness there are so many options!! The city can offer incentives to attract certain types of merchants.

#11 Posted by HereFishyFishy on April 28, 2008 at 4:26 p.m. (Suggest removal)

I agree Fish. We have a city council that has been voted in because of their popularity not because of their competency. I have never heard anything from them that made me stop and say" wow that's a good idea". They don't have any. Why they don't clean up downtown is a mystery to me. We should hire five X marines back from Iraq,(I'm sure they could use the work}and give them our elected officials salaries for a year and let them clean it up.

#12 Posted by docwatson on April 28, 2008 at 5:06 p.m. (Suggest removal)

The city doesn't have to offer incentives.

#13 Posted by BonitaSprings1 on April 28, 2008 at 6:10 p.m. (Suggest removal)

I could possibly be wrong about this but Old Bonita just doesn't seem to ring any bells and whistles of becoming "Downtown". To me, the area of Bonita Beach road and new 41 seem to fit that description much better. Old Bonita, and it is just that, should be remodled and restored as much as possible to maintain the atmosphere of what it was years ago. As far as the former Imperial Landings site is concerned, there could be built something truly astonishing. A center for merchants, galleries and theaters of which this part of Florida has never concieved before. All this, placed in lush tropical surroundings would truly be a shopping, dining and entertainment paradise. There would be no other place like it. It would be the epitome of Old Bonita. Imagination. That is all it takes for a dream to come true. Let the people of Bonita Springs decide what to do with this beautiful piece of land and river. Blessings and be well.

#14 Posted by ravenhawk on April 28, 2008 at 7:38 p.m. (Suggest removal)

I actually went to the park on Old 41 with a friend to enjoy the sun, eat lunch, and just get out of the office. While the park was very nice, there were a number of people wandering about that were clearly unemployed or homeless. My friend was disturbed by this, she said it made her feel unsafe. It's obvious to me that we have a long way yet to go. I don't think we should give up on the area but work together to come up with something we can all be proud of.

#15 Posted by Kianzo on April 28, 2008 at 8:52 p.m. (Suggest removal)

First things first...not a rezone. Establish a separate tax district. Property ownwers in 650 acre blighted area become stakeholders directly contributing and responsible for success.
If Price & Company balk, make them walk, pronto.

#16 Posted by BonitaSprings1 on April 29, 2008 at 12:37 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Kianzo: It's Always wise to carry a gun when you're in that area, especially after the string of robberies in the last 3 weeks.
I wouldn't go with anything lighter than a 357 magnum.
Holster it in a fanny-pack around your waist as most criminals know what a fanny pack is for.
Call (850) 488-5381 to obtain a permit to carry. Requirements are: a clean FBI background check and less than a day of classroom time.

#17 Posted by Naplestango on April 29, 2008 at 6:46 a.m. (Suggest removal)

hypothesis,,,, build imperial landing on a 2 lane road thats already congested with no place to park,,,,,hmmmmm

#18 Posted by Chenzo on April 29, 2008 at 9:51 a.m. (Suggest removal)



Post your comment
(Requires free registration.)

Username:

Password:
(Forgotten your password?)

Your Turn:


The Naples Daily News asked readers to help us build an interactive map of Mother's Day greetings from around Southwest Florida and you responded! The majority of our responses were from Collier County, but we received Mother's Day messages from all over the United States, including Louisiana, Arizona, Tennessee, Ohio, New Jersey, Georgia and Missouri, as well as locations on Florida's East Coast. Find your message on our interactive map of Mother's Day Greetings

News Extras

Daily News Columnists

Participate - Tell Us What's Going On

Tired of being stuck behind that cement mixer? Wondering if you need to buy stock in Bob's Barricades? Check out our Traffic page and get a handle on gridlock. Get live traffic updates from the Collier County Sheriff's Office and local traffic Web sites. Source the cheapest gas in the area with Gasbuddy.com and always be prepared with the latest weather forecast. No matter where you're driving, naplesnews.com has you covered. Get on the road »
BEACH POLL

Summer is right around the corner and The Citizen would like find which area beaches are most popular with our readers and why. TAKE OUR SURVEY and share your opinions. Send your best beach story or comment to news@colliercitizen.com. Results will be published in the July Swimsuit edition.